On November 3, the Supreme Court of India issued a directive that traders who have approached the apex court alleging business losses from protests against Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar must add the protest organisers as parties to their petition. The order was delivered by a three‑judge bench comprising Chief Justice of India Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V Mohana while hearing a series of petitions concerning the anti‑CEC demonstrations.
Court Directs Inclusion of Organisers
The bench specifically instructed the Kirana Committee Delhi to implead the individuals or groups against whom the traders have leveled allegations. By naming the organisers as co‑respondents, the court seeks to ensure that all parties responsible for the alleged disruption are before it, allowing a comprehensive adjudication of the claims.
Senior Advocate Mukul Rohatgi, representing a coalition of trading associations, argued that the protests have severely curtailed commercial activity across Delhi, especially in the central business district of Connaught Place (CP). He highlighted that shops remained closed during the week leading up to the Dussehra festival, a period traditionally marked by heightened consumer spending.
“I represent all trading associations in Delhi… all shops remain closed, there’s nobody in CP today. If you don’t sell during festive season… our sales are down,” Rohatgi told the bench, urging the judges to consider “out‑of‑the‑box” solutions to mitigate the impact on traders.
Traders Cite Losses During Festive Season
Rohatgi emphasized that the timing of the protests coincided with the peak shopping season, noting that the continuation of the shutdown could jeopardise even the upcoming Diwali sales. He described the financial strain on merchants as “people are bleeding,” a vivid illustration of the economic pressure faced by small and medium‑size enterprises.
Solicitor General of India Tushar Mehta, appearing on behalf of the Delhi Police, concurred that the organisers of the bandh must shoulder responsibility for the disruption. He pointed out that permission for the protest at the iconic Jantar Mantar was granted for a single day, yet the demonstrators occupied the site for 17 days, extending the period of commercial inactivity.
Mehta also clarified that while protesters marched towards the Parliament and even the Supreme Court, they could not have proceeded without prior authorization, underscoring the legal requirement for explicit permission before occupying such sensitive locations.
Senior Advocate Menaka Guruswamy, addressing the bench, described Jantar Mantar as a designated protest site and alleged that violence during the demonstrations was perpetrated by the Delhi Police. She referenced the detention of approximately 7,000 individuals, questioning whether the police response aligned with democratic values.
The Solicitor General responded that the individuals were not detained in the legal sense but were merely removed from the protest site, a distinction that the court noted in its deliberations.
Additional senior counsel offered contrasting perspectives. Senior Advocate N. Hariharan argued that the commercial impact stemmed not from the protests themselves but from the barricading measures imposed by the police, raising the issue of proportionality in law‑enforcement actions. Meanwhile, Senior Advocate P.V. Dinesh, representing the Karnataka United Workers’ Union (KUWJ), observed that traders often operate at protest sites as part of a democratic process, stating, “Every site, there would be some trader. It’s a democratic process.”
The bench also permitted interventions from auto‑rickshaw operators and truck operators, who contended that their livelihoods were similarly affected by the prolonged occupation of public spaces.
Judiciary Balances Right to Protest with Public Order
Chief Justice Surya Kant underscored the constitutional right to protest while warning against indefinite occupation of designated sites. “You can’t occupy a site for all times. Where farmers, journalists, etc., will go? Everyone has right to protest. Designated time must be given for designated period,” he remarked, emphasizing the need for temporal limits on demonstrations.
The CJI further stressed that any permission granted for protests must clearly delineate the terms and conditions governing the occupation. “You can’t prevent other people, that I am doing protest now you can’t,” he said, highlighting the principle that one group’s right to demonstrate should not automatically nullify another’s rights.
In response to the traders’ plea for a two‑month moratorium on protests and dharnas, the court did not issue a blanket ban but instead directed the inclusion of protest organisers as parties, thereby opening the door for a detailed assessment of liability, proportionality of police action, and the balance between civil liberties and economic rights.
The Supreme Court’s order reflects an attempt to reconcile competing interests: the fundamental democratic right to assemble and voice dissent, and the legitimate concerns of merchants and transport operators whose livelihoods depend on unhindered commercial activity. By mandating that the organisers be impleaded, the court aims to provide a forum where all claims—commercial loss, police conduct, and protest legitimacy—can be examined side by side.
Legal observers note that the decision may set a precedent for future cases where business communities seek redress for disruptions caused by large‑scale protests. The inclusion of multiple stakeholders—trading associations, auto‑rickshaw and truck operators, and senior counsel representing various viewpoints—demonstrates the court’s willingness to hear a broad spectrum of arguments before arriving at a final determination.
As the case proceeds, the traders hope for a resolution that will allow them to resume normal operations before the lucrative Diwali shopping season, while protest organisers maintain that their demonstrations are a necessary expression of dissent against the Chief Election Commissioner’s actions. The Supreme Court’s next steps will likely focus on the proportionality of police measures, the legality of the extended occupation of Jantar Mantar, and the extent to which the protest’s impact on commerce can be attributed to the organisers versus law‑enforcement actions.






Be First to Comment