Indian chess player VS Rathanvel believed he had clinched the country’s 99th Grandmaster (GM) title after a successful July, only to discover that his official rating had not risen. The discrepancy sparked a months‑long mystery involving tournament pairings, FIDE regulations and a second push for the title.
July tournaments and the missing eight points
At the start of July, Rathanvel was rated 2,492, just eight points shy of the 2,500 threshold required for a GM title. He traveled to Assam to compete in two events – the Ayodhana International and the Guwahati Smart City Open – with the explicit aim of gaining those eight points.
In both tournaments he won every game he played. Across the two events he recorded eleven victories, ten of which came against opponents rated between 1,451 and 1,625, and one against an unrated player. Because FIDE caps the rating gain from a single game at a 400‑point rating gap, each win against the low‑rated opponents contributed only +0.8 points. The ten qualifying wins added up to exactly the eight points Rathanvel needed to move from 2,492 to 2,500.
To preserve his score, Rathanvel took zero‑point byes in several rounds – four in Ayodhana International and five in the Guwahati Open – which meant he faced lower‑rated opponents for the remainder of each Swiss‑pairing. His performance ratings in the two tournaments were 2,225 and 2,299, both below his own rating, and he finished 77th and 246th respectively. The strategy was not to chase a top finish but simply to secure the rating gain required for the GM title.
FIDE regulations and the rating that didn’t change
Despite the flawless record, the August rating list showed Rathanvel’s rating unchanged at 2,492. While over 400 participants in each tournament had their ratings updated, Rathanvel’s own games were omitted from the calculations. The opponents he defeated received rating adjustments, but each of those opponents was recorded as having played one fewer rated game – the missing game being the one against Rathanvel.
Rathanvel told Times of India that he had no clear explanation for the omission and that discussions between FIDE and the All India Chess Federation (AICF) had not yielded satisfactory answers. The current FIDE Title Regulations, effective from 1 January 2024, outline specific circumstances under which games are excluded from title calculations. Clause 1.4.2 states that games against players who do not belong to a FIDE federation, games against unrated players who score zero against rated opponents in round‑robin events, and games decided by forfeit, adjudication or any non‑over‑the‑board means are not counted. Moreover, an entire tournament can be invalidated if changes are made that appear to benefit one or more players, such as altering the number of rounds or providing particular opponents.
Because the regulations allow the Qualification Commission – described as the “final judging unit” for titles – to decide whether a result conforms to the approved formats, the Commission’s interpretation effectively meant Rathanvel’s July games were not eligible for rating gain. Media outlets had already announced him as India’s 99th Grandmaster, only to retract the claim after FIDE’s decision, leaving the player under intense pressure.
Second attempt and final confirmation
Undeterred, Rathanvel set out to earn the required rating again. In October he entered the 22nd Chefchaouen International Open in Morocco. He finished unbeaten with five wins and four draws, scoring 7/9. Notably, he defeated Grandmasters Deep Sengupta and David Larino Nieto. The win against Larino Nieto in round seven, he explained, pushed his live rating to approximately 2,499.7 – a figure that, according to FIDE’s Qualification Commission, can be rounded up to the 2,500 mark for title purposes.
However, his live rating after the tournament was recorded at 2,497.7, still short of the formal threshold. Rathanvel therefore continued competing, and his next event was the Dr. Kantor Sandor Memorial in Debrecen, Hungary. In the opening two rounds he beat Woman FIDE Master Sara Maria Sunea and Grandmaster Attila Czebe, gains that added 3.4 points to his live rating, taking it to 2,501.1 – a figure that leaves no room for rounding debate.
With his norms already secured from earlier performances, the crossing of the 2,500 rating line finally cemented his status as India’s 99th Grandmaster. When asked how the protracted journey felt, Rathanvel said he was “relieved more than celebratory.” He reflected on the four‑year wait for a number, the brief celebration, the subsequent disappearance of the title, and the need to earn it a second time. The experience, he added, left him with a sense of closure that “nobody can take back.”
Rathanvel’s saga highlights the complexities of FIDE’s rating and title regulations, the impact of administrative decisions on players’ careers, and the perseverance required to achieve the highest honors in chess.






Be First to Comment