Advocate Prashant Bhushan appeared before Chief Justice of India Surya Kant on behalf of petitioners Anjali Bharadwaj and Amrita Johri, urging the apex court to intervene in the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of Delhi’s electoral rolls. The petitioners contend that a clarification issued by the Election Commission of India (ECI) on November 3, which permits voters whose names have been removed from the draft roll to file Form 6 as new electors, runs contrary to the Supreme Court’s own observations made the previous week.
Supreme Court hearing and procedural direction
During the hearing, Bhushan highlighted that the ECI’s statement appeared to conflict with the Court’s oral directions of October 28, which had stressed that deleted voters – whose names still appeared in the 2026 rolls – should not be forced to declare for the first time that they have never been enrolled, a requirement embedded in Form 6. The Chief Justice responded that the matter remains pending before the Court and advised the petitioners not to be apprehensive. He instructed them to file an application specifically outlining the ECI’s clarification, noting that the issue is slated for further consideration on November 19. The CJI also indicated that, should the need arise, the Court could direct the Commission to extend any existing deadline.
Election Commission’s November 3 clarification
In its communication addressed to the Chief Electoral Officers of all states and union territories, the ECI clarified that an elector whose name does not appear in the draft electoral roll may submit Form 6 to seek inclusion in the final roll, regardless of prior enrollment. The Commission emphasized that such a submission would not constitute a false declaration merely because the elector had previously been enrolled. It further stated that no action under Section 31 of the Representation of the People Act, 1950, would be initiated against an elector who files Form 6 during or after the SIR, provided the elector is not already enrolled in another parliamentary or assembly constituency and the declaration complies with the law.
The ECI’s position drew on a Delhi High Court observation in Nilotpal Datta v. ECI, which held that individuals using Form 6 to enrol should not fear prosecution for false declaration. The Commission reiterated that the filing of Form 6 by a deleted voter would not, by itself, be false even if the voter had previously cast a ballot.
Petitioners’ objections and broader context
The writ petition challenges the ECI’s approach on several fronts. Firstly, the petitioners argue that requiring voters who were already enrolled to assert that they have never been enrolled exposes them to potential penal consequences under Section 31. They point out that the Supreme Court on October 28 had suggested that voters who have shifted residence should be allowed to use Form 8, which is designed for address changes and correction of electoral entries, while those who missed enumeration forms should be permitted to submit those forms directly.
Secondly, the petitioners note that approximately 47.56 lakh electors have been excluded from Delhi’s draft roll under the “Absent, Shifted, Dead or Duplicate” (ASDD) category. Of these, around 43 lakh are classified as permanently shifted or absent, many of whom claim they never received enumeration forms yet are being asked to apply anew via Form 6. The petitioners’ filing on November 3 urged the Commission to establish a simplified mechanism that would accept Form 8 and enumeration forms from voters on the ASDD list without compelling them to submit Form 6.
In addition, the petitioners highlighted that roughly 31.59 lakh of the deleted voters are marked as permanently shifted and 11.73 lakh as absent or untraceable. They requested that the ASDD list and relevant forms be made available at the booth or block level, with assistance from Booth Level Officers and adequate publicity in Hindi and other regional languages.
The Supreme Court’s October 28 hearing also included a suggestion that the ECI publish the list of deleted voters and facilitate contact between those voters and Booth Level Officers to enable proper form submission. Senior Advocate Dama Seshadri Naidu, representing the ECI, agreed to examine these suggestions and consider remedial measures.
The broader dispute also touches on the Commission’s alleged failure to disclose sufficient information regarding voters who received notices on grounds of “Logical Discrepancies” during the Delhi SIR. The petitioners contend that such lack of transparency hampers affected voters’ ability to respond effectively.
As the court prepares to revisit the matter on November 19, the outcome could shape how millions of Delhi voters are reinstated on the electoral roll and clarify the legal standing of Form 6 in the context of the SIR process. The decision will also test the balance between the Commission’s procedural directives and the Supreme Court’s interpretation of electoral law, particularly concerning the protection of voters from inadvertent false declarations.






Be First to Comment