India’s government is under pressure to eliminate the long‑term capital gains (LTCG) tax on foreign portfolio investors, a move that could bring the country’s tax regime in line with several Asian peers. The proposal comes as foreign ownership of Indian equities has slipped to a record low of 14 percent, according to a Nomura report released on Monday.
Regulatory and industry calls for a tax reversal
India’s capital‑market regulator recently urged the administration to drop the LTCG levy for overseas investors. The appeal was echoed by the PHD Chamber of Commerce and Industry, one of the nation’s oldest business bodies, which last week formally requested the government to abolish the tax. The chamber argued that the tax, which was raised in 2024 while the market was near all‑time highs, now needs to be reassessed as conditions have shifted.
Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman acknowledged the scale of foreign capital outflows on Monday and indicated she would consider the calls for a review, as reported by local media. The timing of these statements coincides with a sharp contraction in foreign investors’ appetite for Indian stocks.
Outflows and the limits of a tax cut
Nomura’s data show that foreign holdings in Indian equities have fallen to an unprecedented 14 percent, a level that underscores the urgency of the debate. While a reduction in the LTCG tax could improve sentiment by aligning India’s tax landscape with other emerging markets, experts caution that a tax cut alone may not be sufficient to reverse the trend.
“A tax cut helps at the margin, but allocators tend to buy expected returns, not tax breaks,” said Amit Bhartia, portfolio manager at Singapore‑based Delorean Partners. Bhartia noted that foreign investors poured roughly 570 billion rupees (about $6 billion) into Indian equities in September 2024, only to withdraw around 940 billion rupees a month later to chase cheaper Chinese stocks. He emphasized that the tax rate remained unchanged during that period; the shift in capital was driven by perceived relative returns.
Outflows peaked in October 2024, marking the highest monthly exit on record until a massive withdrawal in March of the same year. Since then, the market has faced a confluence of headwinds: strained diplomatic ties with the United States, rising energy costs, a weakening rupee, and uncertainty surrounding the impact of artificial intelligence on the economy.
Nomura’s analysis suggests that a combination of an LTCG cut for foreign investors, lower global bond yields, and expectations that the rupee will be supported by central‑bank intervention could provide short‑term support to Indian markets. However, the firm warned that longer‑term concerns about geopolitical and technological uncertainty continue to weigh on growth expectations.
Performance, valuation and broader challenges
India’s benchmark Nifty 50 index has slipped nearly 9 percent year‑to‑date, positioning the country as the world’s third‑worst‑performing market between January and October, trailing only Indonesia and Turkey. Foreign investors, who three years ago hailed India as the top‑performing emerging market, have withdrawn net $18.9 billion in 2025 and more than $30 billion so far this year.
Global brokerage Bernstein warned that India can no longer take capital inflows for granted and will need multiple catalysts—beyond a tax cut—to reverse the outflow trend. The firm highlighted that India’s forward 12‑month price‑to‑earnings ratio stands at 18.6 times, higher than Taiwan’s 16.8 and Korea’s 3.9, despite the latter two markets benefitting from strong artificial‑intelligence‑linked earnings.
On the earnings front, emerging‑market averages are projected to grow 45 percent, while India’s forecast lags at 11 percent, according to Bernstein. This earnings gap contributes to the perception that Indian equities are overvalued relative to their growth prospects.
Hanna Luchnikava‑Schorsch, head of Asia‑Pacific economics at S&P Global Market Intelligence, told CNBC that a tax reduction alone will not trigger a major reallocation into Indian equities because the fundamental trade‑off facing foreign investors remains unchanged. She added that while Indian benchmark indexes have outperformed global peers over the past month—a trend some investors view as a hedge against an AI‑driven rally—sustaining the recent positive capital flows will depend on tangible earnings improvements.
Data from LSEG shows that early‑month foreign capital inflows have turned positive, but the durability of this reversal is uncertain. Luchnikava‑Schorsch emphasized that India’s structural growth narrative is strong, yet investors still require earnings momentum to justify the valuation premium.
In summary, the discussion around scrapping the LTCG tax reflects a broader effort to make Indian equities more attractive to overseas capital. While tax relief could marginally enhance sentiment, market participants stress that without clearer earnings growth and resolution of geopolitical and technological risks, the underlying drivers of foreign outflows are unlikely to dissipate.






Be First to Comment