Press "Enter" to skip to content

Allahabad High Court Rebukes UP Police Over CCTV Failure in Unlawful Detention Case

The Allahabad High Court has issued a stern rebuke to the Uttar Pradesh police, describing the state of civil liberties in the region as “shameful, to say the least” after a habeas corpus petition revealed repeated failures to provide police‑station CCTV recordings. The bench, comprising Justice Atul Sreedharan and Justice Achal Sachdev, said the police appear to have “little regard” for fundamental rights and that infringement of those rights has become routine.

Background of the habeas corpus petition

The petition was filed by the daughter of Afzal Ahmad, who alleged that he was forcibly taken into custody by Bijnor police on 5 September 2026. According to the petition, Ahmad and his daughter arrived at the police station around 2:30 p.m. after being summoned. While they were in their vehicle and had contacted the station house officer (SHO), a car entered the premises near the gate. Four individuals allegedly emerged, surrounded the vehicle and seized Ahmad, taking him away in civil dress.

Ahmad’s formal arrest, however, was recorded only on 7 September 2026, leading his daughter to claim that he had been detained unlawfully for two days. The High Court, acting on the petition, directed that Ahmad be released immediately if he was not wanted in any other case and ordered the state to pay ₹20,000 in costs to the petitioners within seven days.

Court’s scrutiny of CCTV evidence

To verify the allegations, the court had earlier ordered the state to produce CCTV footage from the police station covering the period from 1 p.m. on 5 September 2026 to 10 a.m. on 7 September 2026. The state responded that the recordings for that interval were unavailable. It cited a general diary entry dated 5 September 2026, which noted that a thunderstorm had caused water to trickle down a LAN cable into the CCTV system, leading to a malfunction.

The bench rejected this explanation, noting a pattern of similar excuses in previous cases. “In case after case whenever CCTV footages are called for by this Court, in large majority of the cases, it is the same report which comes stating that CCTV footage is not available on account of one reason or other,” the judges observed. They further clarified that a claim of CCTV malfunction cannot be used as a defence in unlawful detention matters, warning that such an excuse could be interpreted as a deliberate attempt to “obfuscate the truth maliciously”.

Accountability of police officials

The court also singled out the station house officer, identified as Annu Kumari, for deliberately withholding the relevant footage. The bench inferred that the missing recordings were likely detrimental to the police’s position and therefore deliberately suppressed. As a consequence, the judges ordered that a note of displeasure be entered into SHO Kumari’s service record and suggested that the state consider her continued posting in the present role.

Beyond the individual officer, the judgment highlighted a systemic issue: the failure of the broader Uttar Pradesh police infrastructure to maintain functional CCTV systems. The bench referenced a separate matter currently reserved for judgment that addresses the overall failure of CCTV installations across the state.

Implications for civil liberties and police practice

By granting the habeas corpus petition and ordering Ahmad’s release, the Allahabad High Court underscored the judiciary’s role in safeguarding personal liberty when law‑enforcement agencies overstep their authority. The court’s explicit condemnation of the police’s “little regard” for citizens’ rights sends a clear message that procedural safeguards, such as video documentation, are not optional in cases involving deprivation of liberty.

The order to pay ₹20,000 in costs also signals that the state will be held financially accountable for breaching procedural norms. The court’s insistence that the excuse of technical malfunction is insufficient sets a precedent that police departments must ensure the reliability of surveillance equipment, especially when such footage can be pivotal in determining the legality of arrests.

Overall, the judgment reflects growing judicial intolerance for administrative negligence that impinges on fundamental rights. It also raises the prospect of further scrutiny of Uttar Pradesh’s CCTV infrastructure, given the court’s reference to an ongoing case addressing the systemic failure of surveillance systems across the state.

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *