The Supreme Court will hear a petition that questions the internal decision‑making process of the Election Commission of India (ECI) regarding its Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls. The petitioner, Rakesh Kumar Singh, argues that the commission has not produced any contemporaneous documentation to substantiate its claim that all SIR‑related resolutions were taken unanimously by its three members.
Petitioner’s Claims and Rejoinder Affidavit
In a rejoinder affidavit filed through Advocate on Record Mudit Gupta, Singh disputes the commission’s counter‑affidavit, which maintains that the SIR decisions were unanimous. Singh asserts that the ECI has repeatedly asserted collective approval without furnishing any agenda, minutes, file notings, circulation sheets, resolutions, electronic approvals or communications that would demonstrate compliance with Section 18 of the Chief Election Commissioner and Other Election Commissioners (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023.
The affidavit emphasizes that the commission’s admissions—such as the alteration of an online statutory form, re‑allocation of internal work, and the filing of appeals affecting hundreds of thousands of electors without formal commission approval—are statements made by all three members. According to Singh, an assertion of unanimity does not constitute proof, and administrative practice cannot replace statutory authority. He further contends that corrective actions taken after the fact cannot legitimize decisions that may have been made without proper authorization.
Legal Framework and Delegated Authority
Singh’s filing challenges the ECI’s reliance on Section 19A of the Representation of the People Act, 1951, as well as Delegation Orders dated 12 January 1996 and 9 September 2012. He argues that these delegated powers do not extend to altering the statutory electoral registration framework or exercising the commission’s collective decision‑making powers, which are reserved for the full commission under the 2023 Act.
The petition also scrutinises the additional declaration that the commission incorporated into the online Form 6 application during the SIR exercise. Singh maintains that the declaration, which required applicants to provide historical electoral‑roll mapping information—including details about parents or grandparents—effectively introduced a new statutory requirement without amending Form 6 as prescribed by the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960.
While the ECI previously acknowledged before the Supreme Court that displaying the SIR declaration alongside Form 6 could be perceived as an amendment, it insisted that the declaration was a separate document. The commission further argued that the two components were separated in the online process from 21 October, and later removed the declaration from the Form 6 interface altogether, introducing a distinct submission mechanism.
Subsequent Corrections and Their Limited Impact
Singh points out that the ECI’s post‑petition corrective measures do not address the core allegations about the legality of the original decisions. Among the actions cited are a 26 September press note stating that the additional declaration would continue to be used during SIR but that the standard forms would apply outside the SIR period, and the formation of a committee on 26 September and 30 September to examine ECINet portal compliance, later formalised by an 14 October circular.
Further steps include an 21 October decision by the Electoral Rolls Division to separate the SIR declaration from the online Form 6 application, a 4 November office order reallocating oversight of the IT/ICT Division to a Senior Deputy Election Commissioner, and a 6 November direction giving electors marked as Absent, Shifted, Dead or Duplicate (ASDD) another chance to establish eligibility while retaining their existing EPIC numbers.
The petition also references a 3 November clarification on prosecution under Section 31 of the Representation of the People Act, 1950, which stated that previously enrolled voters whose names were absent from draft SIR rolls could submit Form 6 for inclusion in the final rolls without the submission automatically constituting a false declaration.
Singh argues that these later administrative adjustments cannot retroactively validate the original SIR decisions, especially where the commission may have acted without the requisite unanimity under the 2023 Act.
Concrete Examples of Impact
The affidavit highlights a specific incident in Goa where 97 eligible electors were unable to complete the Form 6 application through the ECINet portal, despite repeated requests for assistance. Singh contends that the commission’s failure to facilitate their inclusion illustrates the practical consequences of the additional declaration and the online requirements imposed during SIR.
Another example concerns the filing of appeals against orders of judicial officers in West Bengal during the SIR exercise. Singh alleges that these appeals were lodged by officers of the Chief Electoral Officer’s office without clear authorization from the Election Commission, and that the Chief Electoral Officer was not informed of the basis for the appeals. The petitioner seeks disclosure of the officers responsible for filing the appeals and the authority under which they acted.
Petitioner’s Relief Sought
Singh’s writ petition seeks the production of all original records related to the SIR decisions, including agendas, minutes, file notings, circulation sheets, resolutions, electronic approvals and any other communications that would demonstrate that the decisions were taken in accordance with Section 18 of the 2023 Act. He also requests clarification on whether the delegation orders cited by the commission legitimately cover the modifications made to the electoral‑registration framework.
The Supreme Court has listed the matter for hearing on 17 November, and the petitioner’s rejoinder affidavit will be examined alongside the commission’s counter‑affidavit, which continues to assert the lawfulness and unanimity of the SIR exercise.
Should the court find that the Election Commission failed to produce the required contemporaneous records, it could set a precedent for stricter documentation and transparency standards for future electoral‑roll revisions. Conversely, a finding that the commission’s subsequent corrective actions suffice to legitimize the earlier decisions could reinforce the existing delegation framework.
The hearing is expected to focus not only on procedural compliance but also on the broader implications for electoral integrity, especially given the large number of electors affected by the SIR process across multiple states.






Be First to Comment