On November 18, the Supreme Court of India issued a contempt of court notice to Advocate Pravin Singhal after the lawyer allegedly made derogatory remarks against Chief Justice of India Surya Kant during a hearing on November 16. The notice was issued by a three‑judge bench comprising Justice Dipankar Datta, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V Mohana, following a petition filed by the Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA) seeking criminal contempt proceedings.
Background of the courtroom incident
According to the court record, Advocate Singhal approached a bench that included the Chief Justice, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V Mohana on November 16, requesting an urgent hearing. He claimed to have submitted a matter to the Chief Justice’s office on November 2 and that, after fifteen days, no response had been received. When the Chief Justice asked him to wait for a response, Singhal allegedly refused and directed a personal attack at the Chief Justice, stating, “You can’t sit in that chair, you don’t deserve. You don’t have the integrity for that!”
The outburst prompted the courtroom’s audio‑video feed to be switched off, and security personnel escorted the advocate out of the courtroom. Lawyers present reported that the Chief Justice also recalled prior abusive comments made by Singhal during anti‑Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) agitations, which had previously attracted contempt proceedings.
Court’s procedural response
Following the incident, the SCBA filed a petition seeking criminal contempt action against Singhal. The SCBA President, Senior Advocate Pradeep Rai, emphasized that the remarks made in open court were “completely unacceptable” and clarified that Singhal is not a member of the SCBA. Rai also noted that Singhal had posted an Instagram reel targeting Chief Justice Surya Kant, adding that several individuals monetize social‑media content that attacks judges.
The bench examined the petition, the consent letter from the Attorney General for India, and other relevant records. In the consent letter, Attorney General V Venkataramani described Singhal’s conduct as “extremely scandalous and unpardonable” and recommended action under Section 15(1)(b) of the Contempt of Courts Act. The Solicitor General of India, Tushar Mehta, expressed full support for the SCBA’s plea, stating that the majesty of the Court must be preserved.
After reviewing the material, the bench observed, “We are prima facie satisfied that the motion made by the petitioner SCBA for initiation of proceedings against the sole respondent/alleged contemnor for the alleged derogatory remarks referred to in the petition deserves to be taken forward.” The matter was posted to January for further consideration. The bench directed Advocate Singhal to file a reply affidavit by January 8 and required his personal presence on the returnable date.
Reactions from the legal fraternity
Senior Advocate Pradeep Rai, speaking on behalf of the SCBA, reiterated that the incident undermines the dignity of the judiciary and stressed that the lawyer in question does not belong to the Bar Association. He warned that the misuse of social‑media platforms to target judges is a growing concern, noting that some individuals profit from such content.
Solicitor General Tushar Mehta’s support for the contempt petition highlighted the broader institutional interest in safeguarding the court’s authority. By backing the SCBA’s request, the Solicitor General underscored the view that contempt proceedings are essential to maintain respect for judicial processes.
The Attorney General’s consent, describing the conduct as “extremely scandalous and unpardonable,” provided a statutory basis for the contempt action under Section 15(1)(b), which deals with scandalous or contemptuous remarks made in the presence of the court.
While the bench has not yet rendered a final verdict, the procedural steps outlined—including the filing of a reply affidavit and the requirement for personal appearance—signal that the matter will be examined in detail in the upcoming session. The outcome will likely set a precedent for how the Supreme Court addresses contemptuous behavior by legal practitioners, especially when it intersects with social‑media activity.
Legal analysts note that contempt of court provisions are intended to protect the dignity and authority of the judiciary. The present case, involving both in‑court conduct and external social‑media actions, may broaden the scope of what is considered contemptuous, reinforcing the message that disrespect toward judges will attract swift legal consequences.






Be First to Comment