Press "Enter" to skip to content

Bombay High Court Rebukes BJP Leaders Over Dia Mirza Diwali Firecracker Video

The Bombay High Court on Tuesday issued a sharp rebuke to several BJP politicians who had condemned actress Dia Mirza’s Diwali awareness video as “anti‑Hindu”. A two‑judge division bench, comprising Justice Girish Kulkarni and Justice Dr. Neela Gokhale, said the remarks were “disturbed by the stray comments made by some politicians” and reminded the speakers that India is a secular nation.

Judges stress secularism and the environmental purpose of the campaign

During oral proceedings, the bench observed that festivals are meant for everyone to celebrate and that no individual can be excluded on the basis of religion. “A festival is for everyone to celebrate… No individual can be isolated from celebrating any festival in this country… how can you object to someone’s participation just because that person is from some other religion? Aren’t we a secular country,” the judges said.

The video in question was produced at the request of the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) to raise awareness about the court’s directions prohibiting the bursting of firecrackers on public streets. Mirza, who recorded the message, urged citizens to avoid firecrackers in order to curb air‑pollution ahead of Diwali. Justice Kulkarni praised the actress, noting that she had delivered “a really good message” on air pollution in line with the court’s order.

Justice Gokhale reinforced the environmental framing, stating, “Everyone is breathing the same air, be it anyone,” and adding that banning firecrackers does not strip anyone of the right to celebrate the festival. She referenced the Supreme Court’s observation that Diwali is celebrated by people of all castes and religions, underscoring that the objection was rooted in a misreading of the issue.

Political backlash and the court’s response

The controversy erupted after Mumbai BJP President and MLA Ameet Satam objected to the BMC featuring Mirza in its Diwali campaign. Following Satam’s objection, Mumbai Mayor Ritu Tawde accused Mirza of taking an “anti‑Hindu” and “anti‑Hindutva” stance, claiming that Hindus did not need an actor to teach them how to celebrate Diwali. Maharashtra Minister Nitesh Rane also criticised the actress, questioning why she advocated an environment‑friendly Diwali but did not make similar appeals during Eid, Muharram or Bakri Eid. He alleged that people like Mirza were “against the Sanatan Hindu religion.” Shiv Sena spokesperson Shaina NC added that the city did not need lessons from the actor on Diwali celebrations.

In reaction to these statements, the BMC removed Mirza’s video from its social‑media platforms. The judges described the removal as a “knee‑jerk reaction” and said the objections reflected the views of only a few individuals, urging that such factionalism be avoided when discussing health, pollution and the environment.

Justice Kulkarni noted that the politicians’ remarks were made without reference to the court’s earlier order that permitted everyone to take part in the awareness initiative. He called the subsequent objections “really unfortunate” and emphasized that Mirza had acted in compliance with the court’s directions.

Directions to restore the video and call for communal harmony

The bench concluded by directing the BMC to re‑upload Mirza’s video and to “restore the confidence of the people.” The judges stressed that there was no need for any “loose comment” to disturb the balance of communal harmony, especially in Mumbai, a city that “survives on togetherness and strong feeling of belongingness.” They urged that the matter be closed “on a happy note and in a sense of belongingness,” noting that when the discussion is about health, pollution and the environment, there is “no room for factionalism.”

By ordering the reinstatement of the video, the High Court signalled that civic initiatives aimed at reducing air‑pollution during Diwali are a legitimate public‑interest activity, not a religious provocation. The judges’ remarks also reaffirmed the constitutional principle of secularism, reminding elected representatives that public policy must be guided by law and public welfare rather than sectarian sentiment.

The episode highlights the tension that can arise when environmental measures intersect with cultural celebrations in a diverse society. While some political leaders framed the anti‑firecracker message as an attack on Hindu traditions, the court’s intervention underlined that environmental protection and secular inclusivity are compatible objectives. As Mumbai prepares for the upcoming Diwali festivities, the BMC is expected to resume its public‑awareness campaign, with the reinstated video serving as a reminder that clean air benefits all citizens, irrespective of faith.

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *