Press "Enter" to skip to content

Sonia Gandhi’s Memoir ‘Belonging’ Offers Candid Look at India’s Political Shifts

Veteran Congress leader Sonia Gandhi released her long‑awaited political memoir, Belonging, on the day this article was written. The book, published in the United States by Alfred A. Knopf and in India by HarperCollins, traces her journey from a small town in Italy to the highest echelons of Indian power, while interweaving intimate moments of loss with a six‑decade narrative of the nation’s political transformation.

Gandhi’s account is notable for its openness about private grief. She recounts the death of her first child shortly after birth and describes the unsettling discovery of grenades in a room of her home following the 1984 Operation Blue Star, the military action against Sikh separatists at the Golden Temple. The memoir also offers a ringside view of two of India’s most shocking assassinations: the killing of her mother‑in‑law, former Prime Minister Indira Gandhi, in 1984 and the 1991 murder of her husband, former Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi.

Beyond personal tragedy, Belonging revisits darker chapters that have haunted the Gandhi family and the Congress party. Gandhi reflects on the Emergency declared by Indira Gandhi in June 1975—a 21‑month period marked by suspended civil liberties, mass arrests of political opponents and press censorship—which she says created a rift within the family as well as fear across the country.

1. A Decade‑Long Estrangement From Prime Minister Narendra Modi

One of the most striking passages details Gandhi’s lack of contact with Prime Minister Narendra Modi over the past twelve years. She writes that she has had “practically no real contact” with him during his tenure. On the rare occasions they have shared a room, such as in the speaker’s chamber, Gandhi says Modi “tends to look away, avoiding eye contact.” The memoir notes that the only interaction she recalls is a brief inquiry about her health after a hospital stay.

Gandhi contrasts this with earlier periods of Indian politics when leaders across party lines exchanged courtesies. After the 2001 terrorist attack on the parliament, she immediately called then‑BJP Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee to check on his safety—a gesture she says was appreciated. The decline in personal rapport, she argues, mirrors a broader polarization that has taken root in Indian public life.

2. Loneliness at the Top for Women Leaders

The memoir also explores the isolation experienced by women in Indian politics. Gandhi recalls a 2012 conversation with former U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton about the challenges faced by female leaders. She reflects on her mother‑in‑law, Indira Gandhi, noting that even while wielding supreme authority, Indira felt “besieged and profoundly alone,” especially in the months leading up to the Emergency.

Gandhi describes her own sense of solitude when she assumed the Congress presidency, describing the decision as driven by a sense of duty to her family’s political legacy. The narrative underscores that, despite India’s early history of women in top leadership, the path remains fraught with personal and political loneliness.

3. Growing Stonewalling of the Press

Gandhi points to a marked shift in the relationship between India’s political elite and the media. She recalls an era when journalists could question prime ministers directly in press conferences. By contrast, she observes that Modi has not addressed a single press conference on his own in twelve years of power. The only public press interaction she notes is a briefing at the end of an election campaign and joint press events with U.S. presidents after bilateral meetings, where questions were taken by sympathetic, pro‑government anchors.

The memoir also mentions a widely publicised exchange between Modi and Bollywood actor Ranveer Singh, in which the actor asked the prime minister how he liked to eat mangoes—an anecdote that highlights the limited forum for rigorous journalistic questioning. Gandhi argues that this avoidance of open media scrutiny signals an erosion of democratic conventions.

4. Quiet Fallout With a “Thoroughly Dishonest” Ally

Western political memoirs often name adversaries explicitly. Gandhi, however, adopts a more restrained tone. She writes warmly about the close relationship between the Gandhi family and Bollywood legend Amitabh Bachchan, whose parents hosted her when she first arrived in India. Yet she omits any reference to the later estrangement between the two families.

More intriguingly, Gandhi refers to a political leader she trusted in 1999—during an unsuccessful attempt by Congress to form a coalition government—as “thoroughly dishonest,” without naming the individual. The anonymity suggests a lingering discomfort about publicly airing internal disputes, even as the memoir sheds light on broader political dynamics.

5. Publishing Challenges Reflect a Tense Climate

The book’s publication itself became a flashpoint. Penguin Random House India initially agreed to publish Belonging but withdrew in August, allegedly because the publisher was “uneasy in general with the criticism of the government.” Gandhi claims the decision followed her refusal to make certain editorial changes, a claim Penguin disputes, stating that the cited reason does not accurately reflect the circumstances.

Penguin’s own recent experience—pulling out of distributing graphic journalist Joe Sacco’s The Once and Future Riot about the 2013 Muzaffarnagar communal violence—adds context. While the publisher cited an inaccurate map and citation issues, Sacco blamed the move on “the current political climate in India.” The episode underscores the heightened sensitivity surrounding political content in today’s India.

Through these five takeaways, Gandhi’s memoir paints a portrait of a nation that has moved from a Congress‑dominated secular republic—into which she entered in 1968—to a political landscape now dominated by Hindu nationalism under Narendra Modi. The personal anecdotes, historical reflections and candid observations combine to offer readers a vivid record of India’s evolving democracy, as seen through the eyes of one of its most enduring political figures.

As the book reaches readers in both the United States and India, it is likely to reignite debates about press freedom, political polarization and the role of legacy families in Indian public life. Whether Gandhi’s restrained tone on certain adversaries will satisfy critics or be viewed as a missed opportunity for deeper reckoning remains to be seen.

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *