New analysis comparing data from the Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB) and the Delhi Pollution Control Commission (DPCC) indicates that the official air‑quality index (AQI) for Delhi during the Diwali festival on 8‑9 November omitted a large number of extreme particulate‑matter readings. The omission has led to a stark divergence between the two datasets, with the CPCB’s published figures showing an average concentration of 240 µg per cubic metre, less than half the 551 µg per cubic metre average reported by the DPCC for the same 30 monitoring stations over the same 24‑hour period.
Data discrepancies revealed
During the night of Diwali, three DPCC‑managed stations recorded hourly PM2.5 concentrations that exceeded 3,000 µg per cubic metre, according to the DPCC data examined by BBC Verify. By contrast, the CPCB’s publicly released AQI excluded every hourly reading above the 1,000 µg per cubic metre threshold. The CPCB explained that its monitoring equipment is calibrated only up to that level, and readings beyond it are treated as “outside” the detection range and therefore omitted from calculations.
The CPCB’s own statement said that during “extreme episodes which are occasional like Diwali firecracker bursting, this may appear as a data gap at the particular station concerned, and those hours do not contribute to the 24‑hour average of relevant pollutant for concerned station.” The agency rejected accusations that it deliberately under‑reports pollution, asserting a commitment to “transparent, scientific and reliable reporting.”
Between 21:00 local time on 8 November and 07:00 on 9 November, BBC Verify identified 217 missing hourly PM2.5 observations across 59 CPCB stations. Only 16 stations provided a complete set of readings for that period; the remaining 43 stations each had at least one missing observation. None of the 116 readings above 1,000 µg recorded by the 30 DPCC stations appeared in the CPCB’s dataset.
The missing data have practical consequences. CPCB methodology requires at least 16 valid hourly PM2.5 measurements to calculate a daily average for a station. Stations that fall short are excluded from the city‑wide AQI calculation. One illustrative case is the RK Puram station in south Delhi, where DPCC data showed a peak of nearly 2,500 µg. Using the hourly values from that station, BBC Verify calculated a 24‑hour average of about 945 µg after 17:00 on 8 November. In the CPCB’s published record, the same 24‑hour window yielded an average of only 299 µg because ten hours of extreme readings were missing.
Because of these gaps, CPCB reported Delhi’s AQI at 344 at 16:00 on 9 November, down from 376 at the same time the previous day, despite satellite images and ground‑level data indicating a sharp overnight rise in pollution at several sites.
Health implications and expert commentary
Dr Manoj Kumar, a researcher at the Centre for Research on Energy and Clean Air (CREA), warned that excluding high‑value readings could misrepresent the true pollution exposure faced by residents. He noted that short‑term exposure to extreme PM2.5 levels can cause serious respiratory and cardiovascular effects, and that the World Health Organization’s guideline for annual average PM2.5 is only five µg per cubic metre.
Environmental epidemiologist Dr Sierra Clark of City St George’s University in London added that classifying extreme readings as missing may hide days that contribute most to acute health events such as asthma attacks and heart attacks. She suggested that reporting could be improved by presenting two scenarios: one that reflects typical day‑to‑day pollution levels and another that includes the impact of extreme episodes, thereby offering a fuller picture of public‑health risk.
Satellite observations and broader context
Satellite imagery captured a thick haze over Delhi on 8 and 9 November, confirming that air quality deteriorated during the festival. Measurements of other pollutants—including nitrogen dioxide (NO₂), carbon monoxide (CO) and fire activity—also showed increases on 8 November. However, the overall weekly averages for these gases were not markedly higher than those recorded in the same weeks of 2024 and 2025, suggesting that the spike was largely confined to the Diwali period.
The findings raise questions about the reliability of official air‑quality reporting in a city that regularly ranks among the world’s most polluted. Accurate data are essential for public‑health advisories, policy decisions and public trust. While the CPCB maintains that its methodology follows calibrated equipment limits, critics argue that the exclusion of extreme values creates a systematic under‑statement of risk during episodic events like Diwali firecracker bursts.
As Delhi prepares for future festivals, the debate over data transparency is likely to continue. Stakeholders—including government agencies, researchers, health professionals and the public—are calling for clearer reporting standards that capture both typical and extreme pollution episodes, ensuring that residents receive reliable information to protect their health.






Be First to Comment