Press "Enter" to skip to content

Kerala High Court Urges Review of Juvenile Age Amid Alcohol Violation Claims

The Kerala High Court has signaled that the state legislature should contemplate lowering the age at which a person is classified as a juvenile or a child in conflict with law (CCL) to 16 years. Justice A. Badharudeen articulated the view while hearing a writ petition that also raises concerns about the illegal supply of alcohol to individuals below the age of 23 in the state.

Court Calls for Legislative Amendment on Juvenile Age

During the proceedings, Justice Badharudeen observed that recent trends indicate a level of maturity among 16‑year‑olds that warrants a reassessment of existing statutes. He stated, “it is high time for the legislatures to consider appropriate amendments in the statutes which deal with the ‘juveniles and child in conflict’ with law to reduce age to 16 years, taking note of the present trend showing sufficient maturity by children when they reach the age of 16.” The judge emphasized that any amendment should address the evolving nature of crimes committed by younger individuals.

Writ Petition Highlights Under‑age Alcohol Service and Fatal Crash

The petition before the court seeks accountability from excise officials and licensed bar establishments for allegedly serving alcohol to persons under 23, a violation of Sections 15A and 15B of the Kerala Abkari Act. The petition cites a recent fatal road accident in Nedumbassery, where a Mini Cooper was driven by a 19‑year‑old who was reportedly under the influence of alcohol.

According to the petitioner, Vinod Vikraman Pillai – a journalist who runs an online news portal – the investigation into the Nedumbassery crash revealed that the 19‑year‑old driver had consumed alcohol at several bar establishments in Ernakulam before the incident. The Excise Department has reportedly registered cases against three bars under the Abkari Act for serving alcohol to under‑age patrons.

The court noted that the matter requires a detailed hearing, pointing out that “persons below 18 years of age have caused fatal accidents… after consuming alcohol, taking advantage of the easy supply and availability of liquor to them without any restriction, ignoring the statutory restrictions.” The bench therefore directed the Excise Commissioner to file a statement outlining the directions issued to enforce the statutory mandates that prohibit serving alcohol to anyone under 23.

Petitioner Accuses Corruption and Seeks Stronger Enforcement Measures

The petitioner’s filing alleges a “corrupt criminal nexus” between excise officials, who are public servants, and the management and licensees of specific commercial bar hotels in Ernakulam district. He argues that such a nexus is necessary for under‑age individuals to obtain liquor despite the legal prohibition. The petition contends that the breakdown of preventive excise enforcement threatens the fundamental right to life and personal safety guaranteed under Article 21 of the Indian Constitution.

In response to the alleged violations, the petitioner submitted representations to the Excise Minister, the Excise Commissioner, and the Director of the Vigilance and Anti‑Corruption Bureau (VACB). The representations sought an independent vigilance investigation into the excise officials, binding directives requiring bar hotels to install electronic ID age‑verification systems before serving alcohol, immediate suspension or cancellation of licences for establishments that serve persons below 23, criminal prosecution of those establishments, and the creation of a dedicated 24‑hour public whistle‑blowing hotline under the Excise Intelligence Branch.

Since the petitioner claims that these representations were not considered, he approached the High Court seeking directions to secure the requested reliefs. Counsel for the petitioner, U. Jayakrishnan, presented the case before the bench.

The court has scheduled the matter for further consideration on November 24, allowing the Excise Commissioner time to submit the required statement and enabling the court to examine the broader implications of both the under‑age alcohol issue and the suggestion to lower the juvenile age.

While the court’s remarks on juvenile age focus on the need for legislative amendment, the immediate concern in the petition revolves around enforcement of the Kerala Abkari Act’s age restrictions. The outcome of the November hearing could shape policy directions on both fronts – potentially prompting the state legislature to revisit the age of criminal responsibility and compelling the excise department to tighten compliance mechanisms against illegal alcohol distribution to under‑age patrons.

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *