The Supreme Court on Thursday refused to entertain a petition filed by the Enforcement Directorate (ED) that sought to overturn an interim bail order granted by the Allahabad High Court to Samajwadi Party leader Azam Khan. The bail, issued in a money‑laundering investigation, remains in place pending final adjudication.
Bench declines to interfere with interim relief
A two‑judge bench comprising Justice M.M. Sundresh and Justice P.B. Varale observed that the High Court’s order was limited to interim relief and therefore did not warrant Supreme Court interference. The judges emphasized that the High Court’s findings were only prima facie and should not influence the ultimate decision on the case.
Additional Solicitor General S.V. Raju, representing the ED, argued that the High Court’s grant of bail was improper because the authorities had not supplied the grounds for arrest. The court, however, noted that the grounds had been provided to the ASG and nevertheless declined to set aside the lower court’s interim order.
Legal arguments and procedural backdrop
Senior Advocate Kapil Sibal appeared on behalf of Azam Khan, contesting the ED’s challenge. Earlier, the ED had approached the Supreme Court after the Allahabad High Court, on 17 November, granted Khan interim bail in the money‑laundering case. The ED’s petition was presented to Chief Justice of India Surya Kant the previous day, requesting an urgent hearing. While the CJI agreed to list the matter, he rejected the ED’s request for a status‑quo order that would have suspended the bail.
Khan was arrested on 31 October outside a jail, immediately after securing bail in a separate dual PAN‑card case. He contested the arrest on the basis that procedural safeguards under Article 22(1) of the Constitution were not observed. The High Court concurred, noting that the ED’s actions appeared “mala‑fide” and “motivated,” and that the arrest did not strictly follow the mandated legal procedure.
Origins of the money‑laundering investigation
The underlying ED case stems from a forgery conviction involving Azam Khan and his son, Abdullah Khan. In November of the previous year, a magistrate in Rampur found the duo guilty under Sections 467, 468, 420, 471 and 120‑B of the Indian Penal Code for forgery, cheating, use of forged documents and criminal conspiracy.
The investigation originated from a 2019 FIR lodged by BJP leader Akash Saxena, now a Member of the Legislative Assembly, who alleged that Abdullah had possessed two PAN cards bearing different dates of birth and had exploited the discrepancy for personal gain. According to the prosecution, Abdullah first obtained a PAN card showing a birth date of 1 January 1993, which aligned with his school and high‑school records and was used to open a bank account and file tax returns.
Subsequently, the prosecution alleges that Abdullah altered his bank passbook and the PAN details to submit a forged copy of the passbook along with his nomination papers for the 2017 Uttar Pradesh Assembly elections. The second PAN card reportedly listed a birth date of 30 September 1990, a change intended to satisfy the minimum age requirement of 25 years for contesting the election. The prosecution further contends that this alteration was carried out in conspiracy with his father, Azam Khan.
Additional evidence presented by the prosecution indicated that the bank account referenced in the nomination papers was neither linked to nor operated through the second PAN card, reinforcing the allegation of fraudulent intent.
Following the conviction, the ED initiated money‑laundering proceedings, leading to Abdullah’s arrest on 31 October. The arrest occurred immediately after he emerged from jail having secured bail in the dual PAN‑card matter, prompting Khan to challenge the legality of the arrest before the Allahabad High Court.
The High Court’s interim bail order, issued on 17 November, was subsequently appealed by the ED at the Supreme Court. The apex court’s refusal to disturb the bail underscores the principle that interim orders, especially those based on prima facie observations, are not automatically subject to higher‑court revision unless clear legal errors are demonstrated.
With the Supreme Court’s dismissal of the ED’s petition, Azam Khan remains out of custody while the money‑laundering case proceeds through the regular judicial process. The decision also signals the judiciary’s cautious approach to intervening in lower‑court interim reliefs, particularly when the underlying allegations have not yet been fully examined.






Be First to Comment