The Supreme Court on Friday rejected two petitions filed by the State of Tamil Nadu that asked the Court to direct Karnataka to release an additional 11 thousand million cubic feet (TMC) of water from the Cauvery River. The order was delivered by a two‑judge bench comprising Justice Vikram Nath and Justice Aparesh Singh. While delivering the judgment, Justice Nath also indicated that a third petition submitted by Tamil Nadu on the same day would be dismissed as well.
Background of the dispute
Tamil Nadu’s grievance stems from the water‑sharing arrangement set out in the Cauvery Water Disputes Tribunal award, which allocates the state an annual entitlement of 64 TMC. In earlier proceedings, the state claimed it had received only 14 TMC and argued that, even after accounting for basin‑wide flow deficits, it was entitled to a proportional share of 55.29 percent, leaving a shortfall of roughly 20 TMC.
The state’s latest petitions contended that, up to 6 October, there was a shortfall of 11.719 TMC in the flows measured at Billigundlu, the inter‑state border point. Tamil Nadu further alleged that Karnataka was withholding water despite possessing sufficient reservoir reserves.
Legal and regulatory steps taken
Earlier this year, Tamil Nadu approached the Supreme Court to enforce directions issued by the Cauvery Water Management Authority (CWMA), which had instructed Karnataka to release water in accordance with the award. The state highlighted that Karnataka’s four major Cauvery‑basin reservoirs together held 77.537 TMC of gross storage, including 67.517 TMC of live storage, as of 3 August. Tamil Nadu argued that the CWMA’s order to release 3,500 cusecs for 15 days was inadequate given the circumstances.
The Cauvery Water Regulation Committee (CWRC) had, on 28 July, directed Karnataka to release water from the Krishnaraja Sagar and Kabini reservoirs to ensure a flow of 3,500 cusecs at Biligundlu from 29 July for 15 days. The CWMA endorsed this recommendation at its 54th emergency meeting on 30 July. When Tamil Nadu claimed Karnataka failed to comply, the Supreme Court asked for a status report and reiterated the need for compliance with CWMA directions.
Subsequently, the CWRC raised the recommended release to 12,000 cusecs daily for 15 days beginning 12 August, a recommendation that the CWMA upheld. At a hearing on 17 August, Karnataka disputed Tamil Nadu’s allegations, citing distress conditions in the Cauvery basin, while the Supreme Court again urged Karnataka to adhere to CWMA instructions.
During the 24 August hearing, Tamil Nadu reported that it had received the water released under the CWMA directive as of that morning, but maintained that the authority had not ordered Karnataka to compensate for the deficit in Tamil Nadu’s proportional share. The state pointed to approximately 78 TMC of water stored in Karnataka’s reservoirs and said it would raise the issue again before the CWMA. The Court then adjourned the matter to 31 August.
Supreme Court’s latest ruling
In the most recent order, the bench dismissed the two applications that sought a specific direction for Karnataka to release an additional 11 TMC of water. Justice Nath, before pronouncing the order, noted the filing of a third application on the same day and indicated that it would also be dismissed, although the formal dismissal of that third petition was not part of the written order.
The Court’s decision effectively leaves the existing CWMA and CWRC directives in place, without imposing any new quantitative release requirement on Karnataka. The judgment underscores the Court’s view that Tamil Nadu’s claims of a shortfall and Karnataka’s alleged withholding of water do not, on the record, merit a fresh direction for an 11 TMC release.
While the Supreme Court did not elaborate on the merits of the shortfall calculations, the dismissal signals that the state will need to continue pursuing its relief through the established mechanisms of the CWMA and related regulatory bodies rather than through a direct judicial order for additional water releases.
Legal observers note that the case remains part of a long‑standing and politically sensitive water‑sharing dispute between the two states, with periodic interventions by the tribunal, the CWMA, and the CWRC. The Supreme Court’s recent rulings suggest a preference for allowing the existing inter‑state mechanisms to operate without further judicial imposition, at least until new factual developments emerge.






Be First to Comment