On the day before the first Test of the series in Wellington, India’s bowling coach Morne Morkel said he could not guarantee Mohammed Siraj a place in the playing XI, pointing to the depth of the Indian attack. When the line‑up was announced after the toss on Thursday, 19 November, the team fielded a four‑man pace unit that did not include Siraj.
India’s decision appeared justified early on as New Zealand were bundled out for 70 runs for the loss of five wickets. However, as the Basin Reserve pitch settled, the Indian attack – apart from Jasprit Bumrah – struggled to make further inroads. New Zealand’s Henry Nicholls and Glenn Phillips then took control, steering their side back into the game by the close of the first day.
Selection decisions under the microscope
Batting coach Sitanshu Kotak defended the chosen XI, which featured fast‑bowling newcomers Akash Deep and Anshul Kamboj alongside Prasidh Krishna. Kotar said Siraj’s omission was not a reflection of any flaw in the bowler’s ability. “There is nothing wrong [with Siraj]. I mean I can’t see anything wrong,” he told reporters after day one. Kotak added that the selection was the “best possible XI the team management thought” and noted that Siraj had bowled in both Tests in Sri Lanka, albeit at speeds below his usual pace.
In Sri Lanka, Siraj had taken four wickets across two matches in August, but his reduced velocity was highlighted by the coaching staff as a factor in the current decision. Kotak reiterated that Siraj remains a “world‑class bowler” and that the team’s balance was the priority.
The spin‑bowling all‑rounder slot also sparked discussion. India opted for Washington Sundar over Ravindra Jadeja. Kotak explained that New Zealand’s batting line‑up contained four left‑handers, prompting the choice of an off‑spinner to counter the left‑handed threat. “Not only the first innings, there’s the second innings too. So keeping all that in mind, the decision was made,” he said, while acknowledging Jadeja’s reputation as an “unbelievable all‑rounder”.
Match conditions and the bowlers’ challenges
New Zealand’s recovery was anchored by a 173‑run unbroken partnership for the sixth wicket between Nicholls and Phillips. The pair capitalised on a surface that, although initially damp and grass‑laden (about 15 mm of grass), dried quickly under sunny conditions. Kotak expressed surprise at the rapid flattening of the pitch, noting that the weather was “good” and that the wicket dried faster than the curator had expected.
He also pointed out that the Kookaburra ball tends to lose its seam after 30–35 overs, which reduces the amount of swing and seam movement available to the Indian bowlers. “After 30‑35 overs when the ball gets old, the seam of the Kookaburra ball flattens,” Kotak said, adding that the new ball had offered more assistance earlier in the innings.
While Bumrah’s skill set – his line, length, movement, and ability to make the ball “talk” – was praised, Kotak admitted that the other pacers lacked experience on the non‑Bumrah end. He suggested that the bowlers could have applied more pressure on Phillips, who dominated the off‑side. “We can learn from the way Bumrah bowls and he adjusts the things and the skill he possesses,” Kotak noted, emphasizing the learning opportunity for the younger pace unit.
Looking ahead to the next session
With the second new ball already two overs old, India will aim to replicate Bumrah’s early‑session impact in the upcoming morning spell, hoping to restrict New Zealand’s total to under 300 runs. The coaching staff’s confidence in the selected XI, despite the early setbacks, underscores their belief that the combination of pace, swing and strategic spin will prove effective over the five‑day match.
As the series progresses, the decisions made on day one – from the omission of Siraj and Jadeja to the inclusion of Sundar and the two debutants – will be measured against the evolving pitch and the performances of both sides. Kotak’s comments suggest that the management’s priority is a balanced attack capable of adapting to New Zealand’s left‑handed batting line‑up and the changing conditions at the Basin Reserve.






Be First to Comment